Nvidia’s sell-off tests whether its moat survived the founder’s exit
CR
Cashu Research
Cashu Finance·6 min read
Cashu Research rating
BUY- Target price
- $265.00 USD
- 12 months
- Price at report
- $162.85 USD
- as at 2026-11-13
- Current price
- $150.96 USD
- Implied upside
- +75.5%
TL;DR
- The central argument is that the sell-off reflects uncertainty around leadership and an investigation, rather than a deterioration in Nvidia’s products, customers or growth outlook.
- Nvidia’s recent results provide the foundation for the bullish case.
- The most important risk is the investigation into whether Nvidia hardware reached China through Megaspeed.
The case after the fall
Cashu Research rates Nvidia a BUY with a US$265 12-month price target. Against the US$162.85 last close on 13 November 2026, that target represents an implied return of +63%. The central argument is that the sell-off reflects uncertainty around leadership and an investigation, rather than a deterioration in Nvidia’s products, customers or growth outlook.
Nvidia lost almost 30% of its value since 6 October; founder and CEO Jensen Huang then resigned over personal conduct on 12 November. The board opened an independent investigation into reports involving Huang, a former executive at Nvidia customer Megaspeed, and said it had no reason to believe secrets or national security were compromised. No customer has publicly walked away, no product has been delayed, and the board said operations, customer commitments and the roadmap continue uninterrupted.
Huang’s resignation on 12 November left CFO Colette Kress as interim CEO and director Harvey Jones as the company’s first board chair. A permanent CEO search is under way. The report views the separation of the chair and CEO roles as a governance improvement, while treating the leadership transition as a source of uncertainty rather than evidence that the operating business is in freefall.
The operating numbers still support the thesis
Nvidia’s recent results provide the foundation for the bullish case. Q2 FY27 revenue reached US$96.2 billion, described in the note as a doubling of revenue, while gross margin was 75%. Q3 FY27 guidance was US$108 billion, with gross margin guided to 74% plus or minus 50 basis points.
The Q3 outlook assumes no China data centre revenue, yet consensus was still around US$109 billion. Management had also guided to roughly 70% revenue growth in FY28, with the next-generation Vera Rubin platform in full production. Results and guidance across the supply chain, including foundries and server makers, remained strong, while major cloud companies and AI labs continued spending.
The next catalyst identified in the note is Q3 FY27 results on 17 November. The report’s clean-print scenario is revenue of US$108 billion, gross margin near 74%, and a steady Q4 guide; adjusted EPS of US$2.47 to US$2.49 is the consensus range. In that outcome, the results would suggest that Nvidia’s business can continue operating effectively without its founder.
CUDA is the moat the market may be underestimating
The investment case rests on more than Nvidia’s latest chip cycle. CUDA, the company’s software layer, has been used by developers to run AI on Nvidia chips for nearly two decades. Switching platforms would require customers to rewrite code and retrain teams, which is why the report argues that customers rarely switch once they are embedded in the ecosystem.
Ian Buck, who created CUDA, remains at Nvidia. The report also points to a management bench that already knows the company’s financial and operating rhythm: Kress has been CFO since 2013 and has fronted every earnings call through the AI boom. That continuity is presented as evidence of institutional depth during the CEO search.
Nvidia also retained about US$99 billion of buyback capacity at the end of Q2 and returned US$26 billion to shareholders in that quarter. Repurchasing shares after the sell-off could increase the value of the shares that remain outstanding, although the timing and scale of future buybacks are not guaranteed.
Valuation leaves room for a leadership discount
The valuation argument is straightforward. Nvidia trades at roughly 10.3 times FY28 consensus earnings of US$15.75 per share. The S&P 500 trades near 20 times earnings, while Nvidia’s own five-year average is about 36 times. The report sees that gap as unusually wide for a business still guided to grow revenue by roughly 70% in FY28.
Rather than returning to Nvidia’s historical multiple, the valuation applies 17 times FY28 earnings, below the broader market multiple and less than half Nvidia’s five-year average. Applying 17 times US$15.75 produces US$268, rounded to the US$265 target. The analysis therefore allows for a continuing discount to reflect the investigation and CEO search.
The report’s scenario range shows how sensitive the share price is to the multiple applied to FY28 earnings. A 9-times multiple implies approximately US$142, around 13 times implies US$205, 17 times implies US$265, and 20 times implies approximately US$315. The current price sits near the 10-times case, while the target assumes a partial recovery in investor confidence rather than a return to Nvidia’s own five-year average multiple.
The China investigation is the critical risk
The most important risk is the investigation into whether Nvidia hardware reached China through Megaspeed. US bans cover sales of Nvidia’s most advanced AI chips to China. Megaspeed bought more than US$4.8 billion of Nvidia hardware over two years, and US officials suspect some of it was rerouted to China; Megaspeed denies that allegation. Justice is conducting a criminal investigation, but nobody has been charged.
Recent reporting softened the espionage element of the story. Singapore’s Home Affairs Ministry said Alice Huang was investigated over server declarations rather than espionage, while the US Attorney General said Justice had reached no conclusion on whether she was a spy. Nvidia has retained a major US law firm for its independent review, and a shareholder class action has been filed against Nvidia and Huang.
The report’s most likely outcome is a personal failing by Huang with no corporate wrongdoing. In that case, the investigation overhang lifts and the stock can re-rate. A customer diverting chips without Nvidia’s knowledge would be painful but manageable, potentially bringing fines and tighter compliance. Evidence that Nvidia knowingly enabled sales into China would invalidate the call and imply material further downside.
The report would change its view if evidence showed Nvidia staff knew about or helped chips reach China, if export licence restrictions were imposed on Nvidia or its Asian server partners, or if a major cloud customer cut or delayed orders. It would also reassess the thesis if gross margin fell below the flagged 71% to 72% low with no recovery in sight, or if a wave of senior engineering departures followed Huang’s exit.
Other risks include tougher Washington export rules, competition from AMD and cloud companies’ in-house chips, and a slowdown in AI data centre spending. The report also notes that Huang led Nvidia for 33 years and had dozens of direct reports, so the absence of a named successor could create execution and retention risks.
The conclusion is that this is a leadership and investigation scare attached to a company whose chips, software, customers and cash flow remain intact. The BUY rating and US$265 target depend on the investigation not uncovering corporate wrongdoing, demand remaining strong, and Nvidia appointing a credible permanent CEO.

